Showing posts with label gay organizations. Show all posts
Showing posts with label gay organizations. Show all posts

Monday, November 24, 2025

A Lack Of Self-Love Among Some Black Gay Men

I recently found a letter I forgot I wrote to the editor of the now-defunct New York Native, a weekly gay newspaper. At the time the letter was written, I had edited a black gay supplement for the paper. It was called "Celebrating Ourselves," a title suggested by the poet and novelist Melvin Dixon.

The letter, a response to a reader's letter about Dave Frechette's article, appears to have been written as a draft (with a few editing marks made by me). I'm not sure whether or not it was sent or if it was published.

I started keeping a record of my submissions in a logbook that dates back to February 1987. Anything published before that date would not have been recorded in the book.

If the letter was published, it might be in one of my scrapbooks kept on a high shelf in the backroom closet of my apartment. I'll have to check when I have time. In the meantime, here is the letter as written with the minor edits included. 


18 December 1984

Dear Editor:

J. R. Finney II accuses Dave Frechette (Native 105) of doing the very thing he himself does in his letter-to-the-editor--distorting the truth. Frechette, in his article (Native 101) about the Black and White Men Together** convention in Atlanta, does not, as Finney would have us believe, label as Uncle Toms those blacks who have not heard of the ragtime composer Scott Joplin. (It is possible, J.R., to be an Uncle Tom and know everything there is to know about Joplin.) What Frechette did say--and Finney should re-read the article if he doubts this--is that "a significant segment of the black gay community" sees BWMT "as a breeding ground for Uncle Toms who've rejected their own culture." (The emphasis is mine.)

I have been to several BWMT meetings and one or two social events and I found many of the blacks in the group to be very cold to other blacks while grinning in the face of any white man they found half-way attractive. It seems to me that most, if not all, of the black BWMT members are more apt to be white-identified. They haven't learned that there is no crime or shame in being black or loving other blacks.

Getting back to J.R., I don't know where he got the information that 65% of the black population is unfamiliar with Scott Joplin's name. Did he go door-to-door with a clipboard and a pen asking people, "Have you ever heard of Scott Joplin?" Did he do some kind of "scientific" telephone survey? Perhaps Finney should have said that 65% of blacks in BWMT have never heard of Joplin. That might have been closer to the truth.

In recent years there was a network TV movie about Scott Joplin, starring Billy Dee Williams and a postage stamp commemorating his life and career. Dave Frechette's reference to the 30-year-old  black man was not to berate him for being ignorant about Joplin but to illustrate his disbelief that anyone that old could somehow, in this day of telecommunications, not be exposed to these things. It is indeed a mystery.


Sincerely yours,

Charles Michael Smith

Manhattan


**The group is known today as Men of All Colors Together (MACT).





Saturday, December 28, 2013

BWMT'S Discrimination Documentation Project

Mitchell Karp, a 28-year-old white lawyer, is a member of Black and White Men Together/New York* and  its Discrimination Documentation Project is part of BWMT's efforts to fight racism in the gay community.

Karp is also a staff counselor at Good Old Lower East Side, Inc. (G.O.L.E.S.), a neighborhood preservation company that serves Lower East Side tenants.

Charles Michael Smith: What is your association with the Discrimination Documentation Project?
Mitchell Karp: As a member of Black and White Men Together [who] has recently taken on responsibility as co-chairman for the Political Action Committee, my affiliation is to oversee the Discrimination Documentation Project with the co-chair James Credle. But my other association with the [DDP] is that I serve as one of a number of attorneys that represent BWMT and the complainants  in litigation under the [DDP].

Anyone can be a member of BWMT and anyone can be a member of the project if they're willing to go through the procedure of coming to political action committee meetings. It's an open organization and we solicit input from all members of the gay community. People who call up to complain about racial discrimination are not solely members [of BWMT]. They've heard about it, they've read about it, their friends have told them.

CMS: How did the project originate?
MK: The project was originated by, I believe, the political action committee. At that time, the people that I know that were involved were Henry Wiemhoff, James Credle, and Glenn Rickles. Rickles is an attorney and I think he played a pivotal role in formulating a lot of the guidelines. It was modeled after the NAACP and HUD (Housing and Urban Development), I believe, housing testers. A lot of the same principles and practices were implemented. I was not involved when it was planned so a lot of my knowledge of the history of the project comes through word of mouth. It started in 1980, '81, I believe. The first documentation was at Circles which was a gay bar on the Upper East Side. Eight people were sent in sets of four couples. Two blacks, two whites, two blacks, two whites. All the blacks were stopped and told they had to fill out membership applications and while they were standing there writing out the forms which required information like bank accounts, three friends, names of other members, the four whites, both sets of couples, were welcomed in and asked if they wanted to be on the mailing list. And that was very successful because the first night that we set up the picket line the bar acknowledged responsibility, committed themselves to apologizing to the black members, made a five-hundred-dollar donation to the project and invited everyone in and went through the whole admission of discrimination. I think that was crucial to the success of the project. The bar then changed and became a straight bar called Gotham and then it closed. But we did follow up the project by returning to Circles about six weeks after the demonstration to test once again its policies and, sure enough, all the testers, both black and white, were admitted with no questions asked.

Note: The organization was later renamed Men of All Colors Together (MACT).


The above Q & A interview is an excerpt from an article that was originally published in the New York Native in 1983.

Monday, March 12, 2012

Virginia Apuzzo Speaks Her Mind

This archival interview took place in the offices of the then New York-based National Gay Task Force in 1983. Virginia Apuzzo was the executive director at the time. The interview was published in whole or in part in USA Today and the New York Native, a gay and lesbian weekly newspaper. The following is an excerpt from the interview.

Charles Michael Smith: What type of gay rights legislation do you want to see enacted?
Virginia Apuzzo: First of all, the issue of legislation unfortunately is one that is not clear and clean in terms of how we divide our responsibilities in the gay and lesbian community. Legislation on the federal level has traditionally been the jurisdiction of the Gay Rights National Lobby and I co-chaired that organization from its inception [in 1967] till [the spring of] 1978. But among those things that are on our legislative agenda right now is certainly all of the appropriations legislation that has to do with AIDS. And you see it's the nature of the American system that the budget gets presented and then the Congress approves the budget and then as we needed additional appropriations that emanates from the House and goes to the Senate for confirmation. So we have a legislation that relates to appropriations around AIDS. That's one category. Two, immigration. The National Gay Task Force has had immigration as one of its key concerns since we began. I think there are few people who realize the unfairness of immigration. A person like Elton John or Quentin Crisp can come into the country because they are of high notoriety and are successful and [have] acknowledged sexual preferences. Carl Hill tried to get into the country [and] did not bode as successfully.
The Carl Hill case was the case we just won out in the San Francisco Federal [9th] Circuit District [Court]. The Carl Hill case was decided in our favor that the federal government could not keep him out. That could conceivably be appealed. I'm not sure. We sent a letter to [U.S. Attorney General] William French Smith urging that it not be appealed and also urging that they take the rationale that was confirmed and affirmed by the courts and utilize that to look again at the question of immigration and how they might be much more realistic as far as we're concerned.
CMS: Describe the Carl Hill case briefly.
VA: Carl Hill was from the United Kingdom, Britain, and attempted to come into the country and had a button that identified himself as a homosexual and was stopped and was detained and we predicated our case on utilizing that button to keep him out and his homosexuality is a violation of First Amendment rights. You might also take note of the fact that in the State of California there was a Pacific Telephone case which was litigated and it was determined that coming out is a political act. That therefore the whole question of First Amendment to homosexuality is something we've got to look at very, very carefully. I think that we're in the embryonic stages of the federal government finally beginning to deal with that.
When homosexuality was considered a disease, the [U.S.] Surgeon General could have jurisdiction over saying the person could be kept out because he or she was mentally ill. That's why people have to understand why the American Psychiatric Association and its [statement that homosexuality was not] an illness was so important. It was because the federal government could no longer predicate its argument against [allowing homosexuals into the country] on that argument.
CMS: How active will you be at the Democratic Convention in San Francisco next year?
VA: Very active. It's not just the Democratic Convention. The proper question is, if I may, how active will the gay and lesbian community be in the presidential election in 1984? That's the larger question because we have gay Republicans.
CMS: Does association with the Democrats hurt gays?
VA: No. No. I think that it's important that the gay and lesbian rights movement recognize that our diversity also includes Republicans, Conservatives, Libertarians, Independents. We're in every conceivable political party. My sense is that to the extent that gays and lesbians talk across party lines about the issues that concern us and that's important.
CMS: Is AIDS the biggest issue in the gay community?
VA: No. I think AIDS occupies a lot of our energy and our time but you must understand some things that putting AIDS in its context it certainly has commanded our undivided attention. But we lose 2,000 gays and lesbians a year to alcohol-related deaths. We are suffering from the same health care problems that the rest of America is suffering whether it's Alzheimer's disease or diabetes or hepatitis. We lose people every year to hepatitis. I think what AIDS ought to underscore for us is the dismal state of health care in America today. Sure, my consciousness has been raised through AIDS but my consciousness isn't fenced in by AIDS. AIDS ought to get us to think about all other issues.
CMS: Do you feel the government has done enough to solve the AIDS epidemic?
VA: No, obviously I don't. I've been yelling at them for about a year now. I think government is reactive government. That's probably my chief complaint. It's reactive. It walks an inch and you have to push it to say "That's not the mile, that's an inch." Government only reacts to pressure. So there's the necessity to keep that pressure escalated.
CMS: Has the press informed the public adequately about AIDS?
VA: The press has made a lot of headlines about AIDS. But one area that I would like to see the press look at is the worried well. Do you know what it's like for gay men who have fear all their lives about their sexual identity and having come to grips with that now have to fear their sexuality? That fear is a frantic fear. We've got a problem around stress and AIDS that hasn't begun to be dealt with. There's also some young men with AIDS who have stabilized their condition I think there ought to be more attention to that so that a person who gets diagnosed today doesn't feel like the only outcome is death. The third thing I don't think the press has paid enough attention to is [the fact that] there are 144 women with AIDS. We never read about those women. 54 percent of that group fall in no known risk category.
CMS: What are lesbians doing to fight AIDS?
VA: [There is] a program in which the lesbians in San Diego called Blood Sister donate blood so that gay men who could no longer give blood or were refraining from giving blood would not be left vulnerable. I'd like to see that catch on a lot more. There's a group called Women's AIDS Network nationally that's set up to deal with our concerns about AIDS, It's not exclusively a male phenomenon. But certainly women have been involved in this issue. I've probably talked more about AIDS than just about anybody around nationally.
CMS: Has AIDS strengthened gay solidarity?
VA: I think unfortunately the human being and the community of human beings do come together closer when there is a catastrophe. I think the gay community has done an enormous reassessment of how important it is to itself and to each other.
CMS: Writer Dennis Altman, on a radio show, said that he can't understand any gay or lesbian joining the military. What are your thoughts?
VA: People say that to me all the time. And that's my personal opinion. But we live with certain socio-economic realities in this country and for some people going into the military is a step up. We have to be about choice, about affording people the choices in their life. I wouldn't subscribe to the military but for some people it's the only way out of the situation. We can't judge other people's decision. We can only support them in their choices.
CMS: What did you think of Village Voice writer Anna Mayo's article about federal AIDS research?
VA: I think it ["Grandstanding on AIDS," Voice, November 1] was a homophobic article and it was a sexist article. It was also an article that seemed much more concerned--I think Richard Goldstein answered the article well this week in the Village Voice ["Acquired Mayo Deficiency Syndrome," November 8]. I think it was an absurd article. If Anna Mayo feels that I treated the federal government unfairly, then I would hope that where she feels the federal government treats gays unfairly, she will be equally as volatile in her response to them. But clearly it doesn't bother Anna Mayo that the federal government is the largest single discriminator against gay people and lesbians around. It doesn't faze her at all. The article was a trashy article. It was. I stand by it. If I had an opportunity to do it again, the only way I would alter it is to be more emphatic in my tone.
CMS: Mayo wrote: "[Congressman] Walker (R-Pennsylvania) tried to pin Apuzzo down on her charges of homophobia. Walker asked her--since she had gone on record with such very serious charges--to please name names and identify specific incidents of antigay discrimination in the health field so that he could personally see to it that such discrimination did not continue."
VA: She said I sputtered and I squeaked and if anybody knows me, they know I never squeaked in my life. When I want to say something, I say it pretty out front. The question of institutional or systemic racism or sexism or homophobia is not a ludicrous response. It is a response that underscores the fact that when something like racism or sexism or homophobia is so deep-rooted, people have it as part of the baggage that they carry with them, their perspective, everything about the way they see these populations is viewed by that underlying prejudice. That is my statement and I stand by that statement. And if there are gay people and lesbians who feel that the federal government is not homophobic, well, fine, let them step forward. But in dealing with this issue as in dealing with every other issue, I found institutional homophobia to be a major part of the resistance on the part of the federal government, just as I have found institutional racism and institutional sexism to be the determination in why things are not functioning at a more rapid rate in dealing with issues.

Monday, July 25, 2011

Telling A Story About The Comfort Zone

The following is a letter sent to Paul Schindler, the editor of the New York-based Gay City News. It was written on January 3, 2008:

Dear Paul: I was trying to respond to a comment posted by Mike Holliday at the tail end of my Comfort Zone [underwear sex party] story but was unable to. Holliday wanted an authoritative, analytical , investigative article. I am not an investigative reporter or a gay leader with an ax to grind. I write feature stories; I am a storyteller. "Showing Your Laundry"[ Gay City News, December 20, 2007] is typical of the type of stories I wrote for the New York Native in the eighties. I was documenting a black gay venue so that years from now historians and other academic types will have a written record of it.

As to it being "a puff piece," I disagree. If Holliday had carefully read the story, he would have noted my criticisms. That's why I contrasted the Comfort Zone and Mount Morris Baths. Mount Morris was doing real community service with the many programs it sponsored. For all I know, Holliday might be a disgruntled customer looking for someone to find dirt on the Comfort Zone. That was not my intention. I saw an opportunity to write about a phenomenon that was interesting and about a personality [E.J. Parker] who was compelling and, at times, funny.

I look forward to reading other comments from readers. Two of my friends have read the story. One thought it was hilarious. The other thought I should have been more objective and that I showed anger that Mount Morris [where I was employed for two and a half years] is no longer around. (I disagreed with him about that.)

Anyway, who wants to read a dry as bones, put-you-to-sleep analysis of a sex club in a newspaper?

Monday, March 1, 2010

Harlem Pride

Mark your calendars! Harlem Pride will be celebrating gay liberation June 12-26, in the Mount Morris Park Historic District, on 119th Street, in the center of a thriving "gayborhood." "This historic event," says the press release,"for the first time brings to Harlem, in one location, several LGBT institutions that have been fundamental in fostering tolerance as well as a diverse future." Organizations such as the Audre Lorde Project, SAGE,the Leslie-Lohman Gay Art Foundation, and the Human Rights Campaign will be participating on Harlem Pride Day (June 26), a block-long party, that wraps up the event, a day before the annual Gay Pride Parade downtown. So get ready to party hardy and proudly wear the rainbow colors. For more info, go to www.casafrela.com.

Wednesday, April 29, 2009

So What Do Gay Organizations Do Anyway?

"So what does the Human Rights Campaign do? What does The Task Force do? The name doesn't tell us who it serves. And who knows what the professional glbt groups do. Do we know what the gay/lesbian journalists do? The gay physicians? And do we hear anything from the groups for sociology, psychology, anthropology, history, politics???"--Gay activist Billy Glover, on his blog, "Billy's Musings," March 31, 2009.

Those are good questions. What in deed do these groups do? I've never heard the executive directors of any of these groups interviewed in the major media. What is their agenda? Who are their constituents? What are their operating budgets? What progress have they made over the years?
This is why I've been advocating for a nationally syndicated GLBT terrestrial radio program so that questions like these can be answered. And so that GLBT people and others can have a fruitful dialogue with these leaders.
If such a program or programs existed, Billy Glover's questions could get an immediate response.
In the same blog post, Glover complains about the salaries of the leaders of these organizations. "I suggest that income for these leaders be ended and let's see how many of them are still willing to give some of their spare time--as they earn a living elsewhere as some of us did--to the cause."
First of all, I don't think it would be possible to run such complex organizations in anyone's spare time. It was comparatively easy to set up a group in Glover's heyday. It would be difficult, if not impossible, to fund-raise that way today. You didn't have to have a board of directors, a charter, or a fund-raising committee back then. Plus, times have changed. The world Glover and his friends operated in was a much simpler time. Gays and lesbians were much more on the fringe than is the case today and couldn't be so open.
I don't begrudge gay organizations paying their CEOs a salary. You need competent, knowledgeable, experienced people. And that comes with a price tag, whether we like it or not.
I'm all for organizations being upfront about their finances and their goals, but it takes dollars and expertise to run an organization and we shouldn't demonize or criticize them for that.