Tuesday, September 19, 2023

Pushing Back Against Book Censorship

The banning of literature by civic and religious groups and government officials can have unintended consequences like arousing the public's interest in the banned books and potentially driving up their sales, thereby undermining the ban.

But despite that risk, there are still individuals and groups willing to remove books from classrooms and library shelves in an effort to control what others can read.

To push back against book censorship, the Columbia University Libraries, in conjunction with the New York Public Library, is conducting the 12th annual Morningside Lights The Open Book procession in the Morningside Heights area of Manhattan. The participants will carry 50 plus handmade lanterns honoring various "Great Books," including, no doubt, books that have been banned or challenged as being inappropriate like The Bluest Eye by Toni Morrison.

The event, scheduled for Saturday, September 30, at 8 pm, is "a celebration of the free exchange of ideas," declares a flyer, "and an homage to the libraries that preserve access to knowledge and affirm our freedom to read."

The procession route begins inside Morningside Park at 116th Street and Morningside Avenue. The participants will proceed to the outside of the park, heading north and then west until it reaches its final destination, the campus of nearby Columbia University, probably gathering at the steps of Low Library.

Reminder: Banned Books Week is October 1-7, 2023.

Saturday, September 16, 2023

Remake "The Cotton Club" Movie

Prior to seeing Francis Ford Coppola's film, The Cotton Club in 1984, I had interviewed several people who had either worked at the nightclub or knew someone who did. The interviews were for a syndicated article I was writing about the upcoming movie.

Like the film critic Rex Reed, in his Guide to Movies on TV & Video, 1992-1993 Edition (Warner Books, 1992), I had heard a lot about this "Harlem bastion of glamour, sequins, and jazz that characterized the Roaring Twenties in New York night life."

So when I went to see the film I was full of excitement and high expectations. For the first time I would be seeing the fabled night spot on the big screen, and see an exploration of the lives and working conditions of the black performers who worked there in a Jim Crow environment, in, of all places, Harlem.

And, like Reed, I was disappointed. "[W]here," he asked, "is the Cotton Club? Somewhere on the cutting-room floor."

The movie was more focused on the white gangsters who owned the place than it was on the black performers who were its backbone. This was a missed opportunity to explore the racial and socio-economic aspects of the period. Instead of watching this movie, "You [will] learn more about the Cotton Club," wrote Reed, "and the people who made it famous just by listening to old records by Lena Horne, Cab Calloway, and Ethel Waters." Amen.

In the hands of Spike Lee, Kasi Lemmons, Barry Jenkins, Ryan Coogler, Ava DuVernay, or another capable black director the movie would have been more riveting, more incisive, and more thoughtful. It certainly would have been more black-centered.

If there is one movie that deserves a remake, The Cotton Club is it.

Note: I wrote a similar blog post in February 2015.

The 1984 article I wrote was published in this blog as "Exotic Negroes at the Cotton Club " on February 12, 2013.

Wednesday, September 6, 2023

A "Conversation" With The Body's Internal Organs

During the AIDS epidemic in the 1980s, I thought about writing an article that would be an "interview" with the virus. But I abandoned the idea because I felt with all the hysteria going on at the time, people would think I was making light of a serious health issue.

Eric Spitznagel, a writer and AARP newsletter editor, proves that such a health-related article can be done, using a light touch. His article, "The Inside Story of Your  Body...The Major Players Keeping You Alive Have Their Say" (AARP The Magazine, August/September 2023), is informative, humorous, and entertaining. And it does all three without being frivolous. For example, when Spitznagel asks the liver about liver spots, the organ responds, "Nah, that's a myth. Those spots are actually just skin blemishes caused by sun damage. Nothing to do with me!"

In a "conversation" with such organs as the stomach, the kidneys, the intestines, and the liver, we learn how each organ functions and what can be done to maintain their health, or as Spitznagel puts it, "extend their shelf life."

Each "conversation" with an internal organ has a humorous title and illustration. Three examples: the section about the kidneys and bladder is titled "This Way Out," the section regarding the intestines  is called "The Evacuation Team,"  and the stomach section is called "The Blender in Your Belly."

The article is more fun to read than "I am Joe's Kidney" in Reader's Digest. And the information provided has more staying power in the mind because of how it's presented to the reader.

I hope the magazine publishes more health articles like it.


Thursday, August 24, 2023

Harlem Renaissance Art Comes To The Met

If there were such a thing as a time machine, I would gladly get in it and travel to the 1920s, to my favorite historical period, the Harlem Renaissance.

It would be a thrill to brush shoulders with the likes of Langston Hughes, Zora Neale Hurston, Claude McKay, Countee Cullen, and sundry other writers, musicians, painters, and sculptors. Since that's not possible, the next best thing would be to visit the upcoming exhibition at the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York, slated to run next year from February 25 to July 28. It will be called "The Harlem Renaissance and Transatlantic Modernism."

According to an article in the Arts section of the New York Times ("Met Announces Harlem Renaissance Show," August 23, 2023), the show will be "New York's first major survey in nearly 40 years dedicated to one of the most influential artistic movements to have originated in the United States."

The Met will display artworks by African-American artists that will be on loan from historically black colleges and universities such as Clark Atlanta University and Howard University.

Included in the exhibition will be photographs by another Harlem Renaissance notable, James Van Der Zee.

I'm excited about this event. God willing, I don't plan to miss it.


Thursday, August 10, 2023

Biopics Are Not The Gospel

When one watches a movie based on true events, one should keep in mind that the movie is not a documentary and that the filmmakers for dramatic reasons fictionalize and change details about what really happened.

A case in point would be 2020's One Night in Miami, an otherwise well-done, riveting movie directed by the Oscar-winning actress Regina King.

The movie takes place in February 1964 when Muhammad Ali (formerly Cassius Clay) comes to Miami to vie for the heavyweight championship against his rival Sonny Liston.

Following Ali's victory in the ring, he, the singer Sam Cooke, the firebrand orator Malcolm X, and the football player Jim Brown hole up in a motel room where they share their innermost thoughts, experiences, and aspirations. No one knows for sure what was actually said that night. Kemp Powers, the screenwriter, can only conjecture about what may have occurred, relying on his imagination.

Jim Brown, who recently passed away, was the last surviving participant in that motel gathering and would have known how close Powers came to accurately depicting that night. However, a couple of facts were not accurately presented.

For instance, when Jim Brown and Muhammad Ali are by themselves, Brown expresses to Ali his reluctance to admit to the others that he is giving up his football career to pursue movie acting. What's missing in that scene is Ali telling Brown to relax since he himself appeared in the movie Requiem for a Heavyweight two years prior.

Another scene gets the chronology wrong about when Sam Cooke wrote and recorded "A Change is Gonna Come."  Malcolm goes to the record player and plays Bob Dylan singing "Blowin' in the Wind" and asks Cooke why he hadn't written a song that was as socially and politically relevant. That confrontation, according to the movie, causes Cooke to write "A Change is Gonna Come." Actually, Cooke recorded the song less than a month before the motel gathering in Miami.

Peter Guralnick, Cooke's biographer, in an essay in the companion booklet to the 30-song CD Sam Cooke: Portrait of a Legend, 1951-1964 (2003), relates that after hearing the folk group Peter, Paul, and Mary's hit recording of "Blowin' in the Wind," he told his friend and song publishing partner J.W. Alexander, "Alec, I got to write something. Here's a white boy [Bob Dylan] writing a song like this...." (Guralnick calls "A Change is Gonna Come" Cooke's magnum opus.)

If one were to examine One Night in Miami closely, there are no doubt other inaccuracies. But, hey, that's Hollywood. You can still enjoy the movie. Just don't accept everything you're seeing and hearing as the gospel.

Monday, July 24, 2023

Essex Hemphill, A Remembrance

I encountered the poet Essex Hemphill's writing in 1983. That was when I read his essay, "I am a Homosexual" in the November Men's Issue of Essence, a black women's magazine. (I later reprinted this piece in Fighting Words: Essays by Black Gay Men, an anthology I edited that was published in 1999 by Avon Books/HarperCollins.) I was very impressed  and moved by his straightforward and unapologetic stance on being a black  gay man. I immediately wrote to him at the address that appeared at the end of the essay. I requested an interview, possibly for publication in the New York Native, a weekly gay newspaper. Essex wrote back and included in the package two issues of the black culture magazine Nethula Journal, which he no longer co- published, and two limited-edition boxed chapbooks (Diamonds Was in the Kitty and Plums). Each chapbook came with a certificate of authenticity, signed and numbered by Essex.

Although I never got to do the interview, I did get the opportunity to publish his poetry a short time  later, along with the work of four other poets, in a special black gay supplement in the Native called "Celebrating Ourselves." (The title was suggested by Melvin Dixon, one of the other poets in it.) The rest of the supplement consisted of essays by Joseph Beam, David Frechette, Craig G. Harris, and others, most of whom are now deceased. 

I also got the chance to hear Essex read his poetry in the flesh at Hunter College in New York and at the Friends Center in Philadelphia. At the New York reading (which I think he shared with the lesbian feminist poet Audre Lorde), he went on stage after leaving a nearby men's room where he vomited up a tainted tuna sandwich he bought at the train station in D.C. A real trouper,  Essex gave, as always, a marvelous performance. 

At the Philadelphia reading in 1985, he shared the program with the black lesbian poet Pat Parker. As Essex read his poetry, he stood barefoot at the podium before a gathering of attentive, admiring listeners. His barefoot performance brought to mind those members of my mother's Pentecostal church in Harlem, who, feeling right at home, would walk around the church and among the pews in their stockinged feet. Another fond memory that night was his reading of "Black Beans," a celebration of romantic black gay love.

After the Philadelphia reading, which Joe Beam had invited me to, he led a group of us to a restaurant in nearby Chinatown. Those at the table were Joe; Colin Robinson, a New York writer of Trinidadian heritage; Essex; two other men; and myself. Later we went to a bar/disco called the Smart Place, which primarily catered to a black gay clientele. At the club Joe asked if I wanted to dance. I told him no. From there, the four of us went back to Joe's tiny apartment in the Center City section of Philadelphia. Joe told us that the area was called The Merry-Go-Round because of the constant gay cruising that went on at night. At the apartment, Essex, Colin, and I stayed overnight. Essex and Joe slept on one side of the room, Colin and I on the other.

The next day Essex and Colin left Philly for D.C. and New York respectively. I stayed in town a little while longer. That gave Joe enough time to introduce me to the owner of Giovanni's Room, the gay bookstore where he worked and discovered my writing in the pages of the New York Native. (The bookstore sold the Native each week.) When we got back to his apartment, he let me leaf through the manuscript of In the Life: A Black Gay Anthology, to which I had contributed an article about the Harlem Renaissance writer and artist Richard Bruce Nugent. I remember Joe, who was the book's editor, asking me before letting me touch the manuscript, "Are your hands clean?"

Before Essex and Colin left Philly, we ate at a nearby black-run restaurant. I had scrambled eggs and hash brown potatoes, which Colin paid for. I clearly remember Essex, upon hearing one of the women behind the counter singing, say appreciatively, "Go on and sing it, sister!" As we left the restaurant, Essex gave me a copy of his third chapbook Earth Life. I still have it. Alas, I neglected to have him sign it. But its importance to me has not been diminished.

 In the years since Essex's death in 1995, his name has popped up in several books. One of those books is a Felice Picano novel called The Book of Lies. It's loosely based on the members of the Violet Quill, a real-life white gay literary group that included Picano. In the novel, a character recalled the time in the 1980s when "Essex Hemphill had come up from DC" to do a reading at the Gay Community Center in New York. The character also stated that at the reading "Essex was still doing his fire and brimstone act." Picano's characterization does Essex's memory a disservice. It makes Essex sound like a demagogue, an approach that would have turned off many black gay men. Instead, his eloquent, healing words boosted the morale and self-esteem of black gay men, thereby making him the foremost black gay poet in America, whose work has been widely anthologized and celebrated.

Note: I wrote this essay for Art Mugs the Reaper, an unpublished anthology of literary and visual work by gay men who had died of AIDS. Each individual's work was to be accompanied by a biographical essay. Unfortunately, the editor of the collection, Jeffrey Lilly, a gay San Francisco poet, who had battled health challenges over the years, died in 2019.

This essay, written in December 2000, appears here with several changes to the original text.



Monday, July 17, 2023

An Omnivorous Reader

In his online New York Times obituary (June 14, 2023), Robert Gottlieb, the noted book and magazine editor (Simon & Schuster and Alfred A. Knopf; The New Yorker), was reported to have said that in his teens he read War and Peace by Tolstoy in one day and Proust's  Remembrance of Things Past, described in the obituary as a "monumental" work, in one week.

As a boy, Gottlieb told the Times in a 1980 article, "I would read three to four books a day after school, and could read for 16 hours at a time. Mind you, that's all I did. I belonged to three lending libraries and the public library."

The title of his 2016 memoir, Avid Reader: A Life, which I read and thoroughly enjoyed, is an apt description of his reading habits as a child and as an adult.